Collections and collectors

Access to documents
The result of exchanges between France and India, the collections shed light on the evolution of relations between the two countries since modern times. Their history lies at the crossroads of commercial, political and scientific considerations.

Diverse collector profiles

The circulation of objects between France and India increased in the 18th century. The collections of the Royal Library were enriched with manuscripts at the initiative of Jean-Paul Bignon. He called on Jesuits such as Jean-François Pons, who sent nearly 200 manuscripts from Chandernagor in the 1730s. At the same time, the commercial success of the French East India Company paved the way for an increase in the number of travellers and the development of colonial possessions, multiplying opportunities for collecting. Although the Treaty of Paris (1763) limited the French presence to the five trading posts, collecting continued to develop in a variety of ways.

Travellers, merchants and soldiers known as "adventurers", some of whom were employed by the French East India Company, the East India Company and Indian sovereigns, were eager collectors. Among them were Claude Martin, Antoine Polier and Jean-Baptiste Joseph Gentil. Claude-Auguste Court, Jean-François Allard and Jean-Baptiste Ventura, employed by Ranjit Singh, repatriated collections to France, mainly comprising Indo-Greek and Greco-Bactrian coins.

Colonial administrators such as Édouard Ariel and Philippe-Étienne Ducler were particularly adept at building collections. Branches of the colonial administration also facilitated scientific collecting missions throughout the sub-continent. Victor Jacquemont collected plant and rock samples for the Muséum d'Histoire Naturelle. At the request of the Ministry of Public Instruction, Charles d'Ochoa visited India in 1843-1844 and acquired manuscripts and printed texts. Auguste Lesouëf illustrates the role of collectors based in France.

An overview of collected objects

Over time, collectors' interests evolved, as did the conditions under which objects were acquired and transported, contributing to enriching the typology of collections. In the 18th century, manuscripts, miniatures, weapons and luxury handicrafts figured prominently in collections. These objects illustrate the high level of refinement of Indian civilization, particularly that of the Mughal nobility. Collectors came to acquire them by means of purchases and commissions. Miniatures also had the advantage of being relatively easy to transport on board a ship. In contrast, statues, which were objects of worship, were not easy to obtain. This, combined with the cost of transporting large objects over thousands of kilometres and the prejudices associated with Hindu statuary, explains their relatively low presence in collections built up during this period.

During the 19th century, photography became a major part of the collections. Édouard Manès, Governor of the French Establishments, donated photographs to the Société de Géographie (1887), while the explorer Isabelle Massieu brought back albums from her trip to India and the Himalayas at the end of the 19th century. The collections were also open to audiovisual documents. Albert Kahn's Archives de la Planète project, for example, produced autochromes and black-and-white films.

It is partly through archaeological activities that statues became part of collections. Gabriel Jouveau-Dubreuil excavated sites in South India while teaching in Pondicherry: his name is attached to the collection of Indian statues now housed at the musée Guimet.

The power of collections

Adventurers and administrators gave collections an emotional value. The objects are souvenirs of their stay in India, which explains their desire to bring them back to France.

Collections were also seen as sources on which to build new knowledge about India. All branches of knowledge were involved, from literature and botany to religion, astronomy and medicine.

The objects collected were intended to represent India's history, society and resources. Such is the case of the "Farenghi paintings", works commissioned by Europeans from Indian artists, and photographs, which have in common a focus on subjects such as architecture or the castes and trades. When deployed in a colonial context, this documentary aim took on a political dimension: the objects carried with them the assertion of power over the territories and populations of India.

In addition to these (not mutually exclusive) different uses and meanings, a strictly aesthetic, literary or artistic interest emerged in works depicting the elsewhere, the exotic and the distant.

 

Published in july 2024

Ducler, Philippe Étienne (1778-1840)

Philippe Étienne Ducler (1778-1840), a colonial administrator in Karikal, in the French Settlements of India, built up in a few years a collection of Tamil manuscripts and gouaches, illustrating various subjects, which are today one of the most interesting Indian collections in the BnF.

Emmanuel Francis, CNRS research fellow and statutory member of the Centre d'Études de l'Inde et de l'Asie du Sud - CEIAS.

Lola Vaissaire, graduate student at the École du Louvre, in the “Research in art history applied to collections” program.

Gentil, Jean-Baptiste

Lesouëf, Auguste

Ariel, Édouard (1818-1854)

Édouard Ariel (1818-1854), a colonial administrator in Pondicherry, in the French Settlements in India, built up in a few years a reasoned collection of Tamil manuscripts, which, by its variety and the age of its manuscripts, is unique in the world.

 

Emmanuel Francis, research fellow at the CNRS (French National Centre for Scientific Research) and a statutory member of the Centre for South Asian Studies - CEIAS. 

Margherita Trento, Marie Sk³odowska-Curie post-doc at the CNRS (French National Centre for Scientific Research) and a member of the Centre for South Asian Studies - CEIAS.